|
News
News
SLAUGHTER vs. RESCUE
The rising costs of caring for horses run head-on into the debate over
the ban on killing the animals in U.S. for meat
By Gregory A. Hall •
ghall@courier-journal.com •
April 28, 2008
The movement to ban killing horses for meat has contributed to the closing
of the nation's last horse slaughterhouse and spawned efforts to ban
sending horses to Canada or Mexico for slaughter.
But discoveries of malnourished horses have renewed questions that
perhaps it's necessary to make slaughter available for horse owners. They
could collect maybe a couple hundred dollars by selling an old horse for
slaughter rather than continue to pay thousands a year for care and
feeding -- a situation with which some horse advocates sympathize.
"I understand completely why they do that," said veterinarian Tom Lenz,
of the American Association of Equine Practitioners, which opposes a
slaughter ban. Horses unwanted by their owners -- estimated at more than
100,000 by the American Veterinary Medical Association -- often wind up at
rescue and retirement facilities. Some existing rescue operations report
more calls to pick up horses, and new sites, some at prisons, are planned.
Marcia Moss, the operator of a 4-year-old Bullitt County rescue farm
and slaughter opponent, said she's never had so many people reporting
starving horses or needing to get rid of them as she has in the past
couple of months.
The calls recently have come about every other day. With room for five
horses in addition to one of her own, Moss refers those she can't take to
other rescue groups or finds homes.
The number of horses sent to Mexico for slaughter has totaled 14,000 so
far this year, double the number during the same period a year ago,
according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture.
The Kentucky Department of Agriculture is seeing "a moderate uptick" in
people having trouble finding feed or caring for their horses, although
formal statistics aren't kept, spokesman Bill Clary said.
It was five years ago that reports surfaced that 1986 Kentucky Derby
winner Ferdinand had been killed in a Japanese slaughterhouse. The stories
motivated horse-rescue operations and shocked Americans who weren't aware
that horses are routinely butchered for food in other countries.
Little Cliff savedfrom slaughterhouse
Just a few weeks ago, Little Cliff, a one-time contender for the 2006
Derby, was rescued from being sent to slaughter.
"Let me tell you something, if they're not careful, you'll see another
Ferdinand," said two-time Derby winning trainer Nick Zito, the original
conditioner of Little Cliff.
About the only agreement among slaughter proponents and opponents is
that the increased costs of fuel and food are issues for horse owners.
"It probably has a lot more to do with the drought than anything else,"
Clary said of the increase in reports of unwanted horses in Kentucky.
Last spring's freeze and the summer drought in Kentucky made hay
scarce, and prices remain high. Moss said, for example, that she paid $50
to $75 for a large round bale of hay this winter compared to $25 to $30
the previous winter. Overall, the cost of caring for a horse for a year is
estimated at $1,800 to $2,500 -- if the horse doesn't face any significant
complications. And that estimate doesn't factor in increased costs in fuel
used to transport feed and horses.
Owners in a jamover costs, ban
Those increases have put some owners in a bind.
"I'd say where it used to be the horse owners would try a little harder
… now it's just get rid of them as quick as you can," Moss said.
As costs have risen, horse groups have split over how last year's
elimination of domestic slaughter -- through state laws and court battles
-- factors into in the financial equation.
Horses are still slaughtered -- just elsewhere -- so it's not a factor
in the current situation, contends Diana Pikulski, executive director of
the Thoroughbred Retirement Foundation. "It seems to me it's no different
than it's been for the past 25 years that we've been doing this."
Groups that believe slaughter is needed as an option, however, argue
the closure of the American plants is contributing.
"There is not another option right now that's out there for people who
need to use it," said Tom Persechino, senior marketing director for the
American Quarter Horse Association. The increase in horse shipments to
Mexico was predictable because of the American closures, he said.
"This isn't something that just will go away someday when the prices
(of items such as hay) get better," Lenz said. "I don't buy that at all."
The other options are rescue facilities and euthanasia.
The Unwanted Horse Coalition, which Lenz leads, lists about 200 rescue
sites in the United States and Canada that accept horses. Such sites are
not required to be registered, however, so there could be more.
Whether the available locations are enough to handle the horse
population is debated. Lenz said 6,000 to 10,000 horses a year can be
rescued, but both he and Persechino said the rescue sites can't handle all
the unwanteds.
With thoroughbreds, the Thoroughbred Retirement Foundation operates
about 30 locations throughout the country, including three in Kentucky and
one in Indiana. All told, the foundation's shelters can handle about 1,200
horses with 500 more placed privately, Pikulski said.
One of those is the Maker's Mark Secretariat Center at the Kentucky
Horse Park in Lexington, where horses are trained for other careers.
Rescue centers offera good alternative
Pikulski's group is establishing rescue centers at prisons in Maryland
and Pennsylvania as they have in Kentucky and Indiana. She also said the
group is working with colleges to use retrained horses for their equine
programs.
"There are enough prisons in the United States to find a home for every
single horse coming off the racetrack," Pikulski said. "There are enough
people who want to adopt a thoroughbred racehorse that's sound for riding
to place every single sound horse that comes off the racetrack. There is a
place for every horse, but the people who want to get rid of the horse
have to be responsible."
Churchill Downs Inc. has a Greener Pastures Program in partnership with
the retirement foundation that attempts to facilitate the donation of
horses to the foundation from its tracks.
The 1-year-old, multi-breed Kentucky Equine Humane Center, which
pledges never to turn away a horse in a precarious situation, helped more
than 165 horses last year.
Staci Hancock, president and founder of the center, said its efforts
give any horse owner an alternative to neglecting or sending a horse to
slaughter.
The other option is euthanasia, which can cost $200 or more -- plus
disposal.
Lenz said he expects that euthanasia centers might be needed in the
future. Disposal of a horse can be difficult because of environmental
laws.
Ginny Grulke, executive director of the Kentucky Horse Council, said a
council subcommittee is looking at some sort of statewide effort to geld
stallions and provide euthanasia services.
The issue of unwanted horses needs study, the Kentucky Agriculture
Department's Clary said, taking no position on shelters. "This is
something that needs to be thought out seriously."
Reporter Gregory A. Hall can be reached at (502) 582-4087.
Olympic rider McPherson fined
over horse whipping
Last updated at 01:52am on 28.04.08
Showjumping officials have been accused of covering up a £1,000 fine issued
to a star of Britain's Olympic team for "overwhipping" a horse.
David McPherson was found guilty by the British Show Jumping Association
for hitting Namur47 when it stopped twice at a fence in a contest at
Ardingly, Sussex.
One spectator claimed the mare was left with weals and added: "It was
awful. People were stunned into silence."
The fine was imposed in January but was not made public.
Members of the BSJA's southern committee have complained to their HQ
about the secrecy and the leniency of the fine.
One said: "It should not be brushed under the carpet."
Mr McPherson, 47, who represented South Africa until changing nationality
in 2002, is seen as a key Olympic team member.
The BSJA said it was "not uncommon" to keep rulings secret.
Congress may end slaughter of horses
Meat in U.S. sent to overseas tables
Wednesday, March 14, 2007
Sabrina Eaton
Plain Dealer Bureau
Washington - A battle over Black Beauty that pits agriculture against animal
protection is on the menu in Congress this year.
Horsemeat may not tickle American taste buds, but it's enough of a delicacy in
Europe and Japan to keep three foreign-owned slaughterhouses in Illinois and
Texas busy with exports. In 2005, the plants slaughtered more than 94,000 U.S.
horses.
Legislation pending before Congress would shut them down by banning horse
slaughter in the United States for human consumption. A coalition of horse
groups, animal-rights activists and entertainers like Toby Keith and Ashley Judd
are lobbying for its passage. Groups including Ohio's Farm Bureau oppose it.
Texas oil magnate T. Boone Pickens told a congressional subcommittee last year
that the 2003 death of 1986 Kentucky Derby winner Ferdinand in a Japanese
slaughterhouse galvanized a movement to close U.S. plants. He said the plants,
which boast they can take a horse "from stable to table in four days," provide a
dumping ground for stolen horses.
"The horse has a special place in American culture and history," Pickens said.
"It helped settle this country and provided inspiration for the horsepower that
now powers the vehicles that make this nation go."
Opponents of the bill include Ohio's Farm Bureau, whose members visited
Washington last week to lobby Congress on the issue. They argued that the
legislation injects politics into food policy and could have broader
implications for the U.S. livestock industry.
"This bill would essentially ban a practice that eliminates an opportunity for
the humane end of life for an animal," said Adam Sharp, the farm bureau's
national-affairs director. "What else are you supposed to do with these animals
nobody wants?"
Sharp said it's hard to find facilities that will take in old horses or dispose
of horse carcasses and that burial or incineration of dead horses "gets tricky
and pricey."
Joe Porach, who operates Starlite Stables in Berea, notes the U.S. Department of
Agriculture, which has opposed prior versions of the bill, monitors
slaughterhouse treatment of horses.
"There is a need for the slaughter of horses, and to do away with that is
unacceptable, in my opinion," said Porach, who is vice president of Cuyahoga
County's Farm Bureau.
Phil Greenisen, who raises Haflinger horses in Salem, Ohio, was among those
lobbying against the bill in Washington last week. He says the slaughter market
establishes a minimum baseline price for horses that would fall by about $350
apiece if it were eliminated.
"There are hundreds, if not thousands, of young horses in Ohio that are bought
and sold for a few hundred dollars," said Greenisen. "If this legislation went
into effect, it could mean that my babies would have no value."
The bill passed the House last September in a 263-146 vote but wasn't considered
by the Senate. Rep. John Boehner, the West Chester, Ohio, Republican who was
vice chairman of the House Agriculture Committee before becoming House minority
leader, was the only Ohioan to oppose it. He says it would extend government
regulations too far.
"I do not wish to see any animal unnecessarily harmed," said Boehner. "However,
I do not believe that this legislation is the right way to protect livestock
while ensuring humane ways to dispose of sick and injured animals."
Rep. Dennis Kucinich, the Cleveland Democrat, spoke in favor of the bill on the
House floor. He said horses sold for slaughter are "often transported in
overcrowded trucks, deprived of food and water, exposed to the elements and made
to stand in their own waste."
"The question we must ask ourselves is if subjecting horses to this kind of
circumstance is indeed humane," he said. "Is horse slaughter marked by
compassion, sympathy and consideration for the animal? The only realistic
conclusion is no."
Rep. Marcy Kaptur, the Toledo Democrat, and Rep. Steve LaTourette, the Concord
Township Republican, are co-sponsoring this year's version of the bill.
LaTourette said he doesn't buy farmers' arguments about the bill being the
"slippery slope" toward regulation of other meat products.
"I don't think people should be eating horses," LaTourette said. "You could say,
why not dogs, why not cats? I just don't think it is a good idea. I like eating
hamburger, not horseburger."
Congress isn't the only entity contemplating a crackdown on horse slaughter.
Last week, a federal appeals court determined slaughterhouses in Texas must
comply with a 1949 state law that bars the sale of horse meat for human
consumption. The two Texas slaughterhouses are weighing an appeal to the U.S.
Supreme Court. Legislators in Illinois, where the remaining slaughterhouse is
located, recently introduced a bill that would ban horse slaughter for human
consumption.
"The forces are closing in on this industry on the state and federal level,"
said Nancy Perry, vice president of the Humane Society of the United States, a
nonprofit advocacy group. She calls passage of the federal bill "inevitable,"
adding, "Most Americans don't know this goes on and people who find out are just
shocked."
Perry said owners of unwanted horses can have them humanely euthanized by a
veterinarian. She said some jurisdictions allow dead horses to be buried on
their owners' property, and other horse owners give the carcasses to rendering
companies that melt down the bodies and process them into saleable commodities,
like cosmetics and fertilizer.
Rendering companies in some western states, she says, will pick up dead
livestock if their owners leave $20 in a jar by the body.
"We can't tell other cultures and countries what to do with their horses or
diets," Perry said. "We just don't want our horses abused for their palates."
More
starving horses rescued from farm
By
CHRISTIAN BOONE
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Published on: 02/04/07
Georgia Department of Agriculture officials spent much of Saturday
removing malnourished horses from a Pike County farm, rounding up all
but 27 of the 100 sick equines. State Agriculture Commissioner Tommy
Irvin said Saturday that he was surprised all were still alive.
"So far, we haven't lost any, but many of them are in bad shape,"
Irvin said.
The horses were taken to a private location for security reasons,
where they are receiving food, water and veterinary care. Those that are
sick have been isolated so as not to infect the other horses.
Irvin said some of the horses appear to be suffering from
"strangles," a contagious, upper respiratory tract infection that makes
breathing difficult.
The farm, located about 50 miles south of Atlanta, is owned by Roger
Prater and Bobbie Allison. Prater's attorney, Virgil Brown, said some of
the horses had diseases but were otherwise in good condition.
"There's nothing wrong with the horses," he said.
Irvin said he thinks the couple should be charged with animal
cruelty.
"We feel we have a good case," he said. "This is one of the worst
incidents we've ever seen just because of the numbers involved."
Pike County officials have been investigating the couple and are in
the process of gathering evidence for possible prosecution, Irvin said.
Most of the 50 or so dogs — many of whom appeared malnourished and
poorly groomed — and 65 cattle have been removed from the property.
Meanwhile, 65 goats remain and will be relocated soon, Irvin said.
"The good thing about the goats is they can fend for themselves," he
said.
The Agriculture Department was assisted by the Humane Society of the
United States emergency response team from Florida, animal control
officials from DeKalb, Fayette and Madison counties and the Atlanta
Humane Society.
Irvin said officials expect to round up all the animals by weekend's
end.
Report: Majority of horses healthy on Albany County
ranch
By PHIL WHITE
Star-Tribune correspondent
LARAMIE - A U.S. Bureau of Land Management report found the "vast
majority" of horses kept at a wild horse sanctuary were in good health.
The report, released Friday and written by U.S. Department of
Agriculture veterinarian Al Kane said the group of veterinarians and
state livestock board officials viewed more than half of the 330 horses
kept by Wild Horse Wyoming LLC at the Sheep Mountain Ranch and found
that “the vast majority” were in good condition. The officials were able
to view about 165 horses closely enough to assess body condition in some
detail and another 50 horses at distances that only allowed assessment
of overall condition. Kane estimated that the average body condition of
the horses seen was between 4 ½ and 5 on the Henneke Scale, well within
acceptable levels, according to the Idaho Humane Society.
Veterinarians who inspected the former wild horses west of Laramie
January 11 found nine horses in below-average condition and one very
thin horse which could not rise and was euthanized, according to the
report.
The ranch covers about 23,000 acres “and has good native forage,” Kane’s
report says.
Dr. Kane recommended that the horses be inspected again in 3-4 weeks, or
sooner if severe weather occurs. He also recommended that supplemental
feeding of hay continue, that the horses in worse condition be closely
monitored and that water sources be kept open.
The horse which was put down was about 25 years of age and was
euthanized because of her age, dental abnormalities and weather, not
starvation due to lack of food, the Kane report says.
Three of the horses in below-average condition were feeding on hay near
the headquarters of the ranch, the report states. Their body conditions
were rated at 2.75 to 3 on the Humane Society scale -- numbers that are
not acceptable.
Alan Shepherd, the BLM’s wild horse coordinator, stated in his “Adopter
Compliance Report” that the owner of the horses, Sean Mater of Fort
Collins, “is trying to provide the best care that he can for the horses
on the ranch given the current weather conditions and overall age of his
horses while striving to maintain the ranch’s goal of letting the horses
live out their lives as wild horses.”
Shepherd’s report says the ranch adopted 100 geldings in 2005, ranging
in age from four to 26 years, under a pilot program in which the ranch
agreed to allow the horses to range freely on the ranch for the rest of
their lives in exchange for a payment to the participant of $1,800 per
horse. Between 92 to 94 of these horses are still present on the ranch,
Shepherd said.
Subsequently, the ranch purchased 230 more mares and geldings which “are
the private property of Wild Horses Wyoming and are no longer under BLM
authority,” the report states.
Briton jailed for seeking help for his sick horses
03.02.07
Daniel Robinson
A British backpacker on a 3,000-mile trek across Tibetan China is
languishing in a squalid jail, simply because he crossed the border into
India to seek veterinary help for his horses.
Despite the fact that Daniel Robinson is asthmatic and has suffered
pneumonia, bronchitis and a kidney infection while in jail, the UK
Foreign Office has told his family it can do nothing to help free him.
Robinson was trekking high in the Himalayas at the onset of winter when
his two pack-horses, one of which was pregnant, fell ill. Stranded in
freezing weather and desperate for assistance, he entered a military
zone in northern India without a visa and sought help at an army camp.
He was arrested and accused of spying, though Indian police now accept
that he was not involved in espionage. But Robinson, 38, was jailed for
a year for crossing the border illegally.
Speaking from Haridwar Prison in the northern Indian state of
Uttaranchal, Robinson said: "I knew it wasn't an orthodox way of
entering the country. But I thought the worst I could expect would be a
fine and repatriation to England. Never did I expect to be thrown into
prison.
"I nearly died on the Tibetan plateau. Coming over a freezing mountain
pass at the end, I was suffering from altitude sickness, exhaustion and
dehydration. I really thought it might be the end. But I just couldn't
leave the horses to die up there. Those animals had been through hell
with me and I'd developed a sort of spiritual bond with them."
Barbaro's legacy: saving other horses
Unprecedented medical effort for Kentucky Derby winner gives vets hope
By MARTIN FRANK, The News Journal
Posted Sunday, February 4, 2007
AP/CHRIS GARDNER
From the moment Barbaro's right hind leg crumpled at the Preakness last
May, some said the horse should have been euthanized immediately,
sparing him what proved to be a futile eight-month battle for survival.
But those in the equine veterinary field say, yes, absolutely, it was
worth the effort to try to save him, if for no reason but to save other
horses in the future. It also was worthwhile because now doctors can
expand their research on laminitis, a centuries-old disease in horses
that ultimately led to Barbaro being put down.
Barbaro's treatment at the University of Pennsylvania's New Bolton
Center in Kennett Square, Pa., likely cost owners Roy and Gretchen
Jackson hundreds of thousands of dollars. That expense probably will
prevent most owners from trying to save a horse suffering the same type
of injury.
But it will help those who can afford it.
Dr. Dean Richardson, chief surgeon at New Bolton, fused the bones in
Barbaro's leg, which some veterinarians compared to a "crushed bag of
ice," by inserting 27 screws. That kind of surgery was unprecedented for
a racehorse.
In the end, an all too common horse affliction, laminitis, caused
Barbaro's demise.
"The amazing thing is that the fracture healed, and that's what everyone
needs to remember," said Dr. Rick Arthur, equine medical director for
the California Horse Racing Board, who has done thousands of surgical
procedures on thoroughbreds over the past three decades.
"But it's kind of like the first heart transplant recipient. That person
lived for three or five days after the surgery. From that, doctors could
see how they could make things better so other patients could live
longer. That will happen from what took place with Barbaro.
"So, to those who think this whole thing was a waste of time, I would
say that if you're afraid of failure, you're never going to accomplish
anything."
Richardson admitted that he learned from his treatment of Barbaro, and
that could help him save other horses in the future.
In the past, racehorses injured that badly were euthanized on the spot.
Richardson himself said he had never seen a horse injured so badly
because such a horse "never gets to me."
"If I had a horse come in with the same injury tomorrow, I honestly
believe I'd have a better chance of saving his life," Richardson said.
"And that's because I probably wouldn't make the same mistakes. You have
to believe that you're going to get better at what you do."
Laminitis: 'Cancer for horses'
Veterinarians are in agreement that there wasn't anything else
Richardson could have done about the laminitis, which resulted when
Barbaro compensated for his broken leg by putting too much weight on his
other legs. Richardson tried to prevent it by fitting Barbaro's left
hind hoof with a special shoe less than a week after his injury.
Laminitis is an often-fatal disease in horses caused by an inflammation
of the tissue in the foot, which ultimately cuts off the blood supply to
the foot.
Roy Jackson referred to laminitis as "the cancer for horses." Equine
doctors don't know how to prevent laminitis. They can treat some cases,
but severe cases almost always lead to a horse's death.
Last July, Richardson removed 80 percent of Barbaro's hoof wall in his
left hind leg after a severe case of laminitis developed. The laminitis
returned in Barbaro's final days and spread to his front legs.
That led to the decision to put Barbaro down.
"The entire strategy in [healing Barbaro's leg] was getting the horse to
bear his weight evenly so he wouldn't develop laminitis," Arthur said.
"That can be studied further by what was done with Barbaro."
The horse racing industry is trying to further that research. The
National Thoroughbred Racing Association announced Thursday it has
created the Barbaro Memorial Fund. The money raised will go to the
Laminitis Fund, which was established by the University of Pennsylvania
and the Grayson-Jockey Club Research Foundation.
The NTRA will raise funds at horse racing's Triple Crown races and other
major races.
"I hope people don't get the impression that laminitis isn't a high
priority, because it is, and it always has been," said Ed Bowen,
president of the Grayson-Jockey Club. "Barbaro will give it an extra
boost, he'll keep it on the minds of people, and he'll help generate new
revenue streams for it.
"Barbaro is the poster child for the dangers of laminitis. Veterinarians
will tell you that's the thing that they always fear the most."
Richardson warned about the possibility of laminitis when he first
operated on Barbaro on May 21. He said the same thing last November,
when Barbaro had progressed to the point where he was grazing outside.
Back then, Barbaro was doing so well in his recovery that there was talk
about sending him to a horse farm in Kentucky.
"That was the most frustrating part," Bowen said. "He had overcome an
incredibly complicated and serious injury only to be done in by
laminitis."
Not just about the money
Barbaro's owners, Roy and Gretchen Jackson, of West Grove, Pa., said all
along they were motivated more by their love of the horse rather than
the millions they could have earned had Barbaro recovered enough to
serve as a stud.
Afleet Alex, who won the Preakness and Belmont in 2005, commands a
$40,000 fee for each mare he covers. Most horses have about 100 such
covers in a year.
Afleet Alex, therefore, can bring in $4 million a year for his owners.
Most horses can reproduce well into their 20s.
Barbaro's sire, Dynaformer, commands $100,000 a cover. Barbaro's fee
could have been even higher than that. Artificial insemination is not
allowed in thoroughbred racing.
And if the Jacksons truly were in horse racing for the money, they would
have sold Barbaro for the millions they were offered even before the
Kentucky Derby.
Or, they could have collected a presumably large sum of money from the
insurance policy they had on Barbaro had they euthanized him right after
the Preakness.
The Jacksons said Barbaro was insured, but they wouldn't say for how
much. Barbaro earned more than $2.2 million in his career.
The Jacksons had the money, and they had the desire to save Barbaro. Roy
Jackson's grandfather, William Rockefeller, was president of Standard
Oil. Jackson also owned a minor-league baseball team and served as a
sports agent.
"It's a huge financial decision," said Kimberly May, a former equine
surgeon and spokeswoman for the American Veterinary Medical Association.
"I'm a horse owner and I wouldn't be able to do it because it's way
beyond my means, and it would be the same for a lot of horse owners. If
a horse at Arlington [in Illinois] breaks down, and he's a $5,000
claimer, he's going to be put down.
"It's just a bad business decision to try to save a horse like that."
That wasn't the case for Barbaro.
And it wasn't the case for the equine medical community, which stands to
benefit like never before from a champion racehorse that galvanized race
fans and nonfans alike.
"I just think when veterinarians from around the country sit down and
see the gains that were made," May said, "they're going to be awed by
what was accomplished." Wild Horses Get Adopted
Sixteen former wild horses were up for adoption Saturday at a place you
might not expect -- The Warm Springs Correctional Center in Carson City.
There, an auction was held to place the horses with new owners. The
Bureau of Land Management said inmates at the correctional facility
helped saddle-train the mustangs. According to BLM's Web site, inmates
typically work with the horses for 60 to 120 days. Horses on average
sell for $800 to $1,000, according to the site.
BLM said the horses in Saturday's auction were rounded up in Nevada. Too
many wild horses in the state can make vegetation scarce for other
animals, a BLM official said. BLM's site states there are more than
13,000 wild horses in Nevada.
The next adoption event at Warm Springs Correctional Center will be in
early June. Horses not built to take unlimited punishment
February 9, 2007 12:50 am
HORSES ARE the physical embodiment of Murphy's Law: If something can go
wrong, it will go wrong. This is not a pessimistic attitude. Ask anybody
who owns a horse. Barbaro's owners could certainly attest to this
opinion.
Physically horses are not engineered to survive. They have thin bony
legs with little feet to support and balance 1100 pounds or more. Their
digestive systems are complicated and often malfunction. Their skin is
thin, and they can't see directly in front of themselves because their
eyes are placed too far apart .
However, they make up for their engineering problems with their
intelligence; they seem able to read the human mind. They are graceful,
elegant, powerful, fast and, well, magical.
Even with the best of care and training, horses break easily.
Michael Matz was the trainer of Barbaro. Matz's training methods were
learned from hunter and jumper experience in which horses are carefully,
slowly trained and nurtured to stay as sound as possible for as long as
possible.
Matz trained Barbaro methodically for strength and longevity with cross
training and scheduled rest periods. But still he broke down.
There's an old saying in the horse world: No Foot equals No Horse. It
takes just one injured foot to render the horse unrideable.
Here's why and here's what happened to Barbaro:
After a horse injures one foot/leg he must support all his weight on the
remaining three legs. The extra weight puts a burden on those legs and
feet. Eventually, the opposite leg and foot become sore.
If more time passes, the next leg goes and then the next. A horse cannot
lie down for very long at all because their bodies are too heavy to
withstand their weight pressed down on their muscles, ribs, etc, so they
must be able to stand.
In addition to not being able to relieve a horses' leg/foot pain through
rest, a horse will often stop eating when he is in pain for a long time.
When a horse won't eat, his guts don't work. When his guts don't work,
he colics. Colic is debilitating, extremely painful, life threatening
and often requires surgery. Therefore, No Foot equals No Horse. It's
Murphy's Law.
Copyright 2007 The Free Lance-Star Publishing Company.
Thursday, April 05, 2007
Ala. woman on midnight horse ride charged with DUI after ramming
police car, cops say
Associated Press
SYLVANIA, Ala. -- A woman used a horse to ram a police car during a
midnight ride through town and was charged with driving under the
influence, police said.
DUI charges can apply even if the vehicle has four legs instead of
wheels, Chief Brad Gregg said Tuesday.
Police in the northeast Alabama town received a call around midnight
Saturday about someone riding a horse on a street, Gregg said.
"Cars were passing by having to avoid it, and almost hitting the horse,"
he said.
An officer found Melissa Byrum York, 40, on horseback and tried to stop
her, Gregg said.
"She wouldn't stop," he said. "She kept riding the horse and going on."
After ramming the police car with the horse and riding away, York tried
to jump off but caught her foot in a stirrup, Gregg said. The officer
took her into custody and found she had crystal methamphetamine, a small
amount of marijuana, pills and a small pipe, the chief said.
The horse, which belonged to York, "wasn't in the best of health, but
it's still alive," Gregg said.
York was charged with DUI on suspicion of riding the horse under the
influence of a controlled substance; the nature of the substance was
unclear Wednesday. She also was charged with drug possession, possession
of drug paraphernalia, resisting arrest, assault, attempting to elude
police and cruelty to animals.
York was released from the DeKalb County jail on a $4,000 bond and was
transferred to a jail in another county on an unrelated charge, Gregg
said.
It was unclear Wednesday whether York had a lawyer. A message was left
with DeKalb sheriff's officials.
Horse virus prompts quarantine
The equine herpes virus-1 has stricken two animals at an east Hillsborough horse
farm.
By CHRISTINA K. COSDON
Published April 5, 2007
THONOTOSASSA - A deadly equine virus that frightened horse owners in much of
Florida last year has reached the Tampa Bay area.
State officials quarantined an east Hillsborough horse farm 11 days ago after
two horses there developed the highly contagious equine herpes virus-1 and had
to be euthanized.
The 15 other horses at Cross Creek Farm are being monitored daily by farm
personnel, local veterinarians and state officials. The virus can cause
respiratory disease, abortion and neurologic disease in horses, but is not a
danger to humans.
Keith Powell, who owns the Keilyn hunter-jumper show barn in Lutz with his wife,
said Wednesday that he is making sure all 42 horses at his farm are up to date
on their vaccinations. The main thing, he said, is to build up the horses'
immune systems.
Powell said an outbreak of the virus in Palm Beach County last year kept him
away from horse shows there in January. Instead, he took his horses to shows in
Jacksonville.
"It wasn't so scary when the outbreak was on the East Coast," said Georgann
Powers, who has operated Foxwood hunter-jumper show barn in Pinellas Park for 40
years. "Now it's scary."
The state quarantine on Cross Creek Farm means no horses can be added or removed
from the premises. Workers are being told to disinfect their outer footwear and
wash their hands.
Since the outbreak was confirmed March 25, "there have been no other clinical
signs of the virus," said Michael Short, the equine programs manager in the
state veterinarian's office in Tallahassee. "We're keeping our fingers crossed."
He said quarantines usually are lifted after 21 days if there are no further
signs of the virus, which is spread through the air but also can be carried on
shoes, clothing, hands, feed and equipment.
There is a vaccine for EHV-1, commonly known as rhinopneumonitis or rhino, but
it does not protect against the neurologic strain of the disease. The primary
benefit of the vaccine, Short said, is reducing the chances of the virus
spreading.
State officials aren't sure how the horses at Cross Creek became infected.
The source of the Florida outbreak in November was an infected horse imported
from Europe and brought to Wellington in Palm Beach County. The virus spread to
horses in Jupiter, Indiantown, Morriston, Loxahatchee and Ocala. Ten facilities
were eventually placed under quarantine.
"This is a little more difficult case as far as trying to figure out where it
came from," Short said. "(Cross Creek) is a boarding facility where people do
mostly trail riding. There is minimal movement at this barn. The owners don't do
a lot of showing or traveling."
Short said one possibility is that one of the horses contracted the virus in its
early years and recovered. But "once infected, you're infected for life," he
said.
"That's one thing we don't like about the virus. It's a silent intermittent
carrier," he said. "The virus can be latent for years."
The EHV-1 virus is popping up all over the United States. There are currently
outbreaks in seven states, from California to Maine.
"It's possible that we're seeing a new strain," Short said. "The good news is
that we've found if you use good barn management and cleanliness, it helps
decrease the spread of the disease."
Times staff writer Andrew Meacham contributed to this report.
. Q&A
About the disease
What is equine herpes virus-1?
Equine herpes virus-1 (EHV-1) is a contagious viral disease of horses that can
cause respiratory disease, abortion and occasionally neurologic disease.
How is the EHV-1 disease spread?
It is spread through air and by contaminated objects (feed, clothing, hands,
etc.).
Can EHV-1 spread to humans?
No, but people can transport the virus on their clothes, boots, etc.
Can EHV-1 spread to other animal species?
No.
Is there a vaccine available to help prevent the spread of EHV-1?
Yes, but it doesn't directly protect against the neurological form of the
disease.
How do you test for EHV-1?
A blood test is available. Test results usually take three to seven days to
complete.
Source: Florida Department of Agriculture
08/22/2007
Judge OKs return of neglected horses
Tom McMahon , Staff Writer
LOGAN - Harrison County District Court Judge James Richardson approved an
agreement Monday returning 21 horses to a Woodbine woman originally charged with
neglecting them.
Advertisement
Richardson approved the settlement agreement between Amanda Boyle and Harrison
County in which the state will dismiss 22 counts of animal neglect if Boyle
abides by certain conditions.
Under the agreement, the charges would be dismissed in two years if Boyle
complies with its terms, which include a regular schedule of feeding, cleaning
and providing medical care for the livestock.
Authorities confiscated 23 horses from Boyle's farm May 21 after a veterinarian
determined they needed more care and were malnourished. Since then, the animals
have been cared for at other Harrison County locations.
The agreement stipulates all horses will be returned to Boyle except for two
whose owners requested them back. Most of the animals belong to Boyle.
The agreement stipulates each horse stall be cleaned once a week, the dry lot
cleaned every fall, each horse wormed once per season and examined two times
during the two years and each horse provided proper food and water. Boyle is to
keep specified documentation she is complying, according to the agreement.
The document also states that the Harrison County Sheriff's Office shall have
unrestricted access to the facilities and horses during the two-year period.
Karla Sibert, president of Iowa Equine Rescue and Awareness League, was at
Monday's hearing. The organization's attorney asked Richardson not to accept the
agreement.
"We don't feel the safeguards are sufficient," Sibert said. "Our stand is the
horses should not be returned."
She said Boyle's previous conviction for animal neglect and the number of horses
in her care raise concerns.
In 1994, Boyle pleaded guilty to six counts of animal neglect in Woodbury County
and was sentenced to community service.
"It is clear she neglected them," Sibert said. "I don't understand why they
would return them to her."
Under the agreement's terms, Boyle also agrees to have no more than 44 horses at
any one time until Oct. 31 when the number drops to 40.
Boyle is to reimburse those caring for the animals since they were seized.
"She will have 40 horses," Sibert said. "We recommend one horse per acre unless
you supplement the feed. That would mean she should have nine at the most. The
cost of feeding that many horses would be extremely high."
Should she violate the agreement, Boyle agreed to plead guilty to two counts of
animal neglect and would be sentenced to 60 days in jail and fined between $65
and $625.
Harrison County Attorney Jennifer Mumm did not return phone calls regarding the
case as of this morning.
|